The roberts tax ruling undermines the new health care law. The court could uphold the ppaca entirely, including the individual mandate which requires every person to have insurance coverage or pay a fine. The arguments covered a wide range of topics, including jurisdictional issues, core questions about ppacas constitutionality and the severability of ppacas individual mandate from the rest of its provisions. What the supreme courts upholding of the ppaca means for. On june 28, 2012, the united states supreme court published its decision in national federation of independent business et. The court heard oral arguments march 2628, 2012 and decided the consolidated case.
The court should grant the writ and reassure these hospitals and other providers that they can report, study, and learn from. Florida supreme courts decision, if allowed to stand, will thwart congresss goals in passing the act. Post supreme court decision memo on june 28, 2012, the supreme court issued its long awaited decision on the patient protection and affordable care act of 2010 the aca. The supreme courts decision on national federation of independent business et al v. In last novembers virtual mentor health law column, we summarized some of the key legal issues the court would consider in the aca case, and now we examine their ruling, including the basis for the court. In a 54 majority opinion, the supreme court held that the key provisions of the patient protection and. Since the passage of the patient protection and affordable care act, commonly known as the. Summary single payer is the only remaining constitutional option for truly universal coverage. For the second time in three years, the law survived an encounter with the supreme court.
Department of health and human services et al national federation of independent business et al. Archived from the original pdf on december 30, 2011. Sebelius, challenges the constitutionality of ppaca section 6001, which imposes. Burwell by the supreme court of the united states sent a strong message to critics of. The ppaca patient protection and affordable care act reforms that were passed almost two years ago have been contested in court almost from the moment president obama finished signing the bill several constitutional challenges to the law have rather quickly in terms of the supreme court anyway made it to the very top of the legal chain. The supreme courts decision is important, both as a legal matter and in defense of limited government, but it will not, by itself, achieve good health care policy. Windsor, which dealt with the constitutionality of section 3 of the defense of marriage act doma. In a historymaking decision, the supreme court today ruled that the patient protection and affordable care act ppaca is constitutional under the taxation clause of the constitution. The good news is that even with the supreme courts decision to fully uphold ppaca, the nondiscrimination rules applicable to fully insured group health plans are not yet effective.
The court upheld the constitutionality of the acas individual mandate, whi. Supreme court on june 28, 2012 upheld most provisions of the patient protection and affordable care act ppaca, but rejected the portion of the law that authorized the government to penalize states that do not accept the expanded eligibility provision for medicaid. Even if the individual mandate is necessary to the affordable care acts other reforms. Impact on health benefi t plans o n june 26, 20, the supreme court issued the longawaited ruling in united states v. For example, a case pending in the fifth circuit court of appeals, physician hospitals v. The ppaca and the court the patient protection and affordable care act ppaca and the decisions by the us supreme court on its constitutionality raise some of these same concerns. Twentyfive states brought this case to the supreme court. The congressional budget office cbo and the staff of the joint committee on taxation jct have updated their estimates of the budgetary effects of the health insurance coverage provisions of the affordable care act aca to take into account the supreme court decision issued on june 28, 2012. Supreme court ruling on the patient protection and. Santa clara county, california certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the ninth circuit no.
Supreme court upholds healthcare reform law in a 54 vote, the supreme court has upheld the patient protection and affordable care act pdf as constitutional, although the medicaid expansion. Supreme court of the united states syllabus astra usa, inc. The patient protection and affordable care act the act or aca is a. Supreme court decision on the case known as the national federation of independent business v. Supreme court has upheld the significant healthcare reform provisions in the patient protection and affordable care act ppaca, enacted by congress in 2010 in a sharply divided vote along partisan political lines and subsequently challenged on constitutional grounds by 26. Court strikes down the mandate as unconstitutional, and possibly guaranteed issue, guaranteed renewal, and community rating as well, but upholds the rest of ppaca. Upholding the affordable care act under the commerce clause would give. Argued january 19, 2011decided march 29, 2011 section 340b of the public health services act imposes ceilings on. The court could find that the individual mandate is unconstitutional, but uphold the balance of. House of representatives, house legislative counsels manual on drafting. The election, 20 and beyond law360, new york july 20, 2012, 12. Fall out from the supreme courts affordable care act decision. Constitutional challenges to the patient protection and affordable. The first decision, in 2012, was fractured and grudging.
The patient protection and affordable care act, the supreme court, and the 2012 elections 6 ppaca. Therefore, republicans can use reconciliation to repeal any ppaca provisions passed through reconciliation. Leading voice for physicians in georgia disappointed with supreme court decision, stresses patients will struggle to find access to medical care atlanta the medical association of georgia mag is disappointed with todays u. Obamacare supreme court ruling upholds health care reform. Status of the aca medicaid expansion after supreme court ruling. The district court lifted the stay on sba lists action and eventually dismissed it, concluding that sba list did not present a sufficiently concrete injury for standing or ripeness. Status of the aca medicaid expansion after supreme court. The supreme courts 54 decision determined the constitutionality of two key substantive. Nationwide, over 2,200 hospitals participate in patient safety organizations. The affordable care act extends medicaid coverage to otherwise eligible. A guide to the supreme courts decision on the acas. Supreme court ruling to uphold the patient protection and affordable care act ppaca, according to mag. The most controversial provision was the individual mandate or minimum essential coverage provision that establishes the requirement that nearly all. Sebelius, secretary of health and human services, 2 which, in short, upheld the provisions of the patient protection and affordable care act, 3 with the exception of the medicaid expansion provisions.
Supreme court upheld the insurance mandate that is the centerpiece of the patient protection and affordable care act nfib v. Democrats employed this procedure to amend the health carelaw. Supreme court issued its decision in the case challenging the affordable care act aca. Several ppaca cases remain outstanding and need to be resolved. The full text of the supreme courts decision in the healthcare case. Kathleen sebelius, secretary of health and human services, et al and department of health and human services et al. Legal memorandum reconsidering the constitutionality of obamacare. The court upheld the entire law, holding that congress acted within its constitutional authority when enacting the individual. Two states both challenged and supported the patient protection and affordable care act ppaca, 11 states supported it, and 12 states took no position on it.
Supreme court has issued its longawaited decision addressing the constitutional challenges to the landmark health reform legislation. United states department of health and human services. The supreme courts ppaca decision our own limited role. The supreme court obamacare ruling was a 54 ruling to uphold the affordable care act. Ppaca insurance mandate is upheld 54 mandate survives as a tax, but not via commerce clause justice roberts, a conservative judge, represented the deciding vote medicaid regulation requirement enforcement deemed not constitutional yesterday, the supreme court. Supreme court on june 28, 2012, upheld key provisions of the. Supreme court to decide the future of the health care.
There are three potential outcomes of the courts decision. The 2012 elections if the supreme court rules that the individual mandate is unconstitutional and is not severable from the rest of ppaca, the court will strike down the entire law. Administration challenges acas preexisting conditions. Supreme court allows nationwide health care subsidies. Supreme court upheld key provisions of the patient protection and affordable care act aca after 26 states had challenged its constitutionality in lower courts. The patient protection and affordable care act grew out of a long history of failed. In march 2010, president obama signed into law the patient protection and affordable care act the act or aca, which is felt to be the most comprehensive. On november 14, 2011, the supreme court of the united states issued a writ of certiorari to the united states appeals court for the eleventh circuit to consider appeals to its rulings in national federation of independent business v. Supreme court regarding the constitutionality of the individual mandate under the patient protection and affordable care act. Readers are requested to notify the reporter of decisions, supreme court of the. It is apparent to the undersigned that the controversy ignited by the passage of the legislation at issue in this case will eventually require a decision by the supreme court after the abovedescribed litigation works its way through the various circuit courts. There are limits to congresss commerce power and use of the necessary and proper clause there are limits to congresss ability to coerce through spending the individual mandate is a tax.
The decision will have widespread impact and political implications in the future. Affordable care act cases, set of three legal casesflorida et al. Status of the aca medicaid expansion after supreme court ruling 4 fiscal impact of the medicaid expansion on state budgets medicaid is administered as a partnership jointly funded by the federal government and states, with the federal government contributing. The decision on the obamacare ruling by the supreme court in national federation of independent business v. Supreme court announced its decision on the constitutionality of the health care reform law. Sebelius came on the last day of the courts 20112012 term. Constitutional challenges to the patient protection and. The view from 50,000 feet the decision is an affirmation of the constitutions federalist structure. Supreme court watchers already are studying closely the writings and speeches of justice anthony kennedy, hoping to discern where his potential swing vote might turn a 54 decision. The attorneys general argue that a supreme court decision in 2012 saved the aca from being declared an unconstitutional overreach of congressional power by declaring the penalty a. Supreme court decision on the affordable care act ncbi. Bolton said that prior to the ruling, it was widely felt that the supreme court would uphold.
1207 967 1219 1554 1500 705 534 1112 618 159 829 1511 1365 1301 114 696 666 334 582 847 869 896 543 431 780 1428 281 290 933 1521 463 1182 738 1090 366 822 781 112 889 220 547